Kate Spade Carla or MBMJ Lovely Aline Tote?

Okay so I just recently bought both since there have been such great sales, but the best thing would to only keep one. So which one should it be? I also already have bags of both sizes and similar styles, so it's not a matter of which is more fit for me, but which looks better!

So help me pick!

prodImage.ms


or

pKS1-3838150reg.jpg


Both were fantastic prices, Kate Spade a little under 200, and MBMJ being 280.
 
i vote for the mbymj because i have this bag. i have it in the light chestnut color, and i do love this bag. the leather is buttery and soft. it's a nice bag.