Michael Kors Juicy bag -- or Michael Kors bag? Which one is better?

[Wildflower]

Please help me choose!

I have a few MK bags and I do like them... I always tend to like the Astor styles with the studs. Am looking for a brown tote with handles and a shoulder strap and came across these two -- now I can't decide.

Have never owned anything from Juicy, so not sure of the quality... love this style -- but not so crazy about the chain and tassles on it (and perhaps it's detachable?) but especially love the one strap:

http://shop.nordstrom.com/S/3012673...Y&origin=category&searchtype=&pbo=6007596&P=1

Then I found this Michael Kors bag and I like it, too:

http://shop.nordstrom.com/S/3020445/0~2376779~6008000~2384925?mediumthumbnail=Y&origin=category&searchtype=&pbo=2384925&P=1

Which one would be a better choice?

 

[tonij2000]

I like the MK better but my daughter has a leather JC bag and it's very nice, well made and everything!

 

[chelsae]

My vote goes to the MK.

 

[Vinyl]

I prefer the JC bag.

 

[mzbag]

I was falling for JC then MK came along pretty handbags.

 

[Wildflower]

Thanks for the replies! Love getting other opinons.

I like the color of the Juicy better and the single strap... but don't like the chain on it. Tassels aren't toooo bad but would probably remove them if possible.

I like the handheld handles on the MK and like the shoulder strap very much, but don't like the chain part of it...

Retail on both bags is pretty close, but the JC is on sale...

Just having a hard time deciding on this choice!

 

[LushBoutique]

It seems like your interests are pretty much the same for both. I like the JC better and its on sale!! Good deal! good luck and let us know what you choose.

 

[LushBoutique]

o..and especially since you already have MK bags, I'd say go with some variety and get the JC but its totally up to you. Have you seen them IRL and tried them on and felt them?

 

[Wildflower]

^^No... I live about 3 hours away from any major city that would carry them which is why I always have to buy online.

I think I'm going to order the JC and if I don't care for it, then I'll exchange it for the MK bag. Nordies is always so good about doing exchanges -- have done it a couple of times but don't want to do it too often, so I really try to have a solid decision before ordering.

Thanks again everybody!

 

[lark_lulu]

I prefer the MK.

 

[shosho811]

i prefer the MK one....

the colour and style seems better also not sure of the durability of the JC

 

[PurseAddict79]

I actually like the JC better than the Kors bag. The leather looks more smooshy and the color is richer...

 

[IrisCole]

I prefer the MK - but it's mainly because I'm not a fan of the fringe tassle on the JC bag.

 

[BagsRmyLife]

Michael Kors!

 

[afsweet]

i like the JC a lot more. i think JC leather bags are actually pretty well made. mine have never given me any problems.