I say #2 or #3. I am also very pale and 5'2'' and I can't wear trench coats in that color because it makes my skin look sickly. I think the trench has the possibility to hit your leg much lower than it does on the model and could be a bad length for shirt girls like us.
juicygrl: I tried the sample and it hits me above the knee. I kind of wish I could wear it as a minidress the way it's shown on the runway, but hey - at least it's not too long!
aquahot: All 3 are Burberry. The first is SS10 and the other two are FW10.