Is this D&G Sicily bag too big for me?

[fdc]

Hi everyone,
I bought this Sicily bag in Medium size, I tend to use it everyday for work.
I’ve recently received and when try on I think it’s a tad too big for me as I’m very thin and lean more on petite side (162 cm). Even my husband thinks that it’s too big for me so I’d like to know from your thoughts.
Thanks in advance!

 

[Vanilla Bean]

I think it's a perfect size for you as a day bag. That said, I'm not a fan of tiny bags. I think they look juvenile instead of classy. I love the color too but I don't know that a pale pink bag can handle being an everyday work bag. Too easy to get dirty and scuffed.

 

[whateve]

I think it looks fine on you.

 

[rose60610]

It's looks very nice and appropriate, especially when you say it's for everyday and work. The Sicily is one of my favorites. Gorgeous.

 

[ccbaggirl89]

I do think it looks a bit oversized, not by much, but a slightly smaller bag would be more in proportion. The only way it looks fine is handheld - the other two ways - shoulder and in front add bulk to you, you look weighed down. It's pretty though!

 

[Mariapia]

I think it's great on you!

 

[fdc]

I think it's a perfect size for you as a day bag. That said, I'm not a fan of tiny bags. I think they look juvenile instead of classy. I love the color too but I don't know that a pale pink bag can handle being an everyday work bag. Too easy to get dirty and scuffed.

I think it looks fine on you.

It's looks very nice and appropriate, especially when you say it's for everyday and work. The Sicily is one of my favorites. Gorgeous.

I do think it looks a bit oversized, not by much, but a slightly smaller bag would be more in proportion. The only way it looks fine is handheld - the other two ways - shoulder and in front add bulk to you, you look weighed down. It's pretty though!

I think it's great on you!

Hi dears,
Thank you all for your reply.
I’m still hesitating whether I should keep the Sicily bag, especially when today I went shopping and found some other “interesting” bags *sigh*
Please tell me what do you think of them below.
(Excuse my dirty shoes it was raining outside!)

Salvatore Ferragamo 1

 

[fdc]

Salvatore Ferragamo 2

This little bag can be good as a transitioned day-to-night bag and it holds just my every day essentials: make up pouch, my Gucci card holder that serves as wallet, my public transport card and my keys.

 

[fdc]

Gucci
I like everything about this bag: the size, the leather, color and functionality, except its logo I find it a bit too showing off for work.

What do you think? TIA

 

[Vanilla Bean]

I like the Ferragamo. Very much like the first bag but just a little smaller.

 

[Luv n bags]

I like the D&G. The lines are so clean. It may be a tad bit big on you, but, as another poster stated, small bags look off on an adult. My second choice would be the Gucci. Not loving the Big GG’s for everyday wear.

 

[ccbaggirl89]

Another vote for the Ferragamo. The second one looks like a toy bag, too small.

 

[Venessa84]

I think the Sicily looks perfect on you and not too big. My 2nd vote is the Gucci and then the Ferragamo.

 

[fdc]

I like the Ferragamo. Very much like the first bag but just a little smaller.

Exactly they have a smaller size but not in the color that I like, otherwise it’d be the perfect combo ughh

I like the D&G. The lines are so clean. It may be a tad bit big on you, but, as another poster stated, small bags look off on an adult. My second choice would be the Gucci. Not loving the Big GG’s for everyday wear.

Yeah I think small bags are more suitable for night events than daywear!

Another vote for the Ferragamo. The second one looks like a toy bag, too small.

You’re right it’s pretty small, I was just wondering if sometimes I can wear it for night event straight after work even when it’d happen twice a year lol

I think the Sicily looks perfect on you and not too big. My 2nd vote is the Gucci and then the Ferragamo.

Thank you and everyone else for your insight

I’ll let you know once I make up my mind xo

 

[anitalilac]

My pick:
1. D&G Sicily
2. Ferragamo