Is there a real difference between Premier Designer bags and Designer

BgaHolic

Emma 4ever in my <3
O.G.
May 23, 2009
7,341
131
NYC
or is really in the mind of the beholder. Lately, I am feeling more frugal. Perhaps it's more mounting expenses but the more I look at manufacturers like Cole Haan or MBMJ, I am not seeing a major difference in the workmanship of the bags compared to a Longchamp for instance.

Anyone care to give their thoughts? :biggrin:
 

mielikki55

Member
Nov 21, 2006
1,395
2
IMHO, I think a lot of it is all in our heads. For the most part, I think you're paying for the label name. Obviously, some of the premier designer bags will use exotic leathers/skins, but that's different than workmanship. I've had premier designer bags fall apart on me and designer bags that last forever.
 

sarafina77

Wool Vixen
Jul 9, 2008
3,776
2
Vancouver, WA
I so so feel you girl. I've sold all my chanel bags and am in love with my MBMJ right now.

i think the quality issues with a lot of premier brands have turned a lot of us off.

Now if I could just lose the Balenciaga bug... lol
 

SDBagLover

O.G.
Jan 7, 2010
3,378
1,667
San Diego
While I am sure I will always lust for many of the "premium" designer bags, recently I've become a huge fan of Marc by Marc Jacobs bags. I think they are a really good value and something I don't feel guilty about buying because I use them frequently. They are soft, well made and just so darn cute, I find myself using them more than many of my higher end bags. They seem like a good value for a great design, great function and great comfort. I just picked up today a MBMJ crossbody bag that is so comfortable on the shoulder, I could wear it everyday. I also like Cole Haan. There is an outlet near me so it's really fun to find some amazing CH bargains there. Both the MBMJ and Cole Haan are very well made, IMO.
 

kimalee

Member
Jul 30, 2007
17,669
19
I so so feel you girl. I've sold all my chanel bags and am in love with my MBMJ right now.

i think the quality issues with a lot of premier brands have turned a lot of us off.

Now if I could just lose the Balenciaga bug... lol
I'm also on the MbMJ bandwagon! I just can't get enough of the amazing leathers, fun colors, and chunky hardware. Besides, I don't think any of the 'premier designers' offer that much better quality. (Excluding Hermes, perhaps!:P)
 

doreenjoy

zzz
Feb 6, 2008
10,642
51
I think Hermes and BV use the best materials, and still have a reputation for the best workmanship.

I have no problem with carrying "lower end" bags but I think those two brands still have quality. Don't get me started on Chanel and LV...I think all they have now is marketing. Their workmanship has disappointed me in recent years.
 

katdhoneybee

Meditate on that.
Jan 25, 2010
553
1
Phoenix, AZ
www.stylecrank.com
I have both, and I think it depends on the brand. Sure, marketing is always involved, but there really can be a big difference in the quality of the materials and the construction. The key is being able to look beyond the hype and identify the best value for your money.

Case in point: I have several Botkier bags and have been very impressed with the quality of the leather, how "solid" they feel, and how well they hold up. I also own a Bulga hobo that started to fall apart within the first two weeks (WTF?!). Those brands are around the same retail price. Meanwhile, I own several MJ collection bags, and even though I'm impressed by Botkier, I can tell that the MJ bags are higher quality. And in terms of design, more timeless. I am willing to pay more for this.

All that being said, carrying my MJs doesn't make me feel more special than when I carry the Botkiers. To me, it's about what I love and the value I get for my money. Which brings me to my last point, which is that I buy all my bags secondhand. My (fabulous, glamorous, interminably chic) grandmother always said, "Never pay retail." I subscribe to that. And it's allowed me to maximize the return on my investment, so to speak.
 

papertiger

MOD
Moderator
Authenticator
O.G.
May 23, 2009
42,524
63,479
G-orgeous H-eaven
Very good fundamental Question BH

I have all sorts - I just go with what my heart and head take me bag by bag :broom:.

Although I admit I do look at 'premier' things first for the latest season it doesn't mean I don't look elsewhere.

Only very recently I found 2 bags under my bed from years ago I had forgotten about, one from Jigsaw and one from All Saints. I've already taken both out since, and these are not even 'designer' they are just 'high-street'.

It depends where I go and what I need and sometimes not even that but just what I like and what goes with my outfit.

:rtr:Having said that when I buy a premier designer bag I buy it with the intention of carrying it to my own funeral :nuts:. Not as a monetary investment but an investment in my 'core' style. When I buy a less-expensive bag I may want to keep it forever but I wouldn't feel bad at all if in a couple of years I just gave it away or similar.
 

LoveCatsLots

Member
Mar 5, 2009
595
2
I'll go with your mind/eye of the beholder theory, but IMO, what plays a larger role is whether one can afford to buy the pricier premier designers. I strictly limit how much I spend on handbags, shoes and scarves, but I have friends who have no need to limit themselves. I believe I'm a savvier shopper than my wealthy friends, because I look at the quality of the handbag rather than its name and trendiness.

I have favorite designers like Chanel, Prada and Gucci, but I own other designers, because what I wear is driven by event and setting. I love Prada for everyday wear and traveling, Chanel for the opera and symphony, but I wouldn't wear Prada or Chanel to a football game or to a water park.

I buy handbags that appeal to me, but I keep an eye on the bottom line. When I'm out and about, I have attitude, so I'm comfortable wearing any handbag that I love whether it's a Coach, a vintage D&B or a Chanel.

:heart:
 

Janinevs

O.G.
Feb 4, 2007
1,426
2
I haven't really noticed a difference in the quality in my bags, except for maybe BV, but I might be biased, I just love that bag so much. And yes, MJ is amazing!! I have stuff from his main line, the diffusion line and the special items and love them all equally!
 

Janinevs

O.G.
Feb 4, 2007
1,426
2
Oh and Cole Haan quality is excellent! I tend to always buy their wallets and they hold up so well.
 

someday681

O.G.
Oct 2, 2009
1,139
0
The South
I think it really varies brand to brand...and sometimes within a certain brand. I have seen some designer bags that could rival most premier designer bags in quality, and others by the same designer that looked like they would fall apart in a month.
 

vanbruntsa

purses/shoes/bling!
O.G.
Feb 16, 2008
1,726
25
Probably not a huge difference but I really hate to buy a bag and then turn around and find it on massive markdown. I stopped buying bags that went on sale bc of this...so this limits me on the brands I buy.