If you had to chose.....

[pursemama]

I love these bags equally, but not too sure on which one would be more of a classic style. I was hoping you guys would give me your input...negative or positive.

in black though or

they're just about the same price. I have a few MJacobs, but not in this style...always wanted one in this style.

 

[Swanky]

I like texture so I naturally lean towards the black quilted bag.
I think both are pretty timeless, but the black is slightly more IMO.

 

[scarlett_2005]

I like the black one the best. The other one is ok. I don't really like the shape or the straps on the side. Jmo. Good luck with your choice.

 

[jag]

I love both bags- seriously but there is just something about the quilted leather that I really love. The first one reminds me of a typical MJ bag (which is not a bad thing) while the quilted just stands out more and will always be a classic- never go out of style really. Either way, you can't go wrong. Let us know what you decide!

 

[Cristina]

I like the yellow (is that considered yellow?) one The black one is nice, but it's a little too shiny for me, almost patent leather-like.

 

[edsbgrl]

As far as being a more classic bag, I'd go with the black one.

 

[purselova34]

I like the black one better. I think it get more use. The first looks very seasonal imo.

 

[pursemama]

Thanks all for your input...I knew I could count you! They're actually the same bag, but in different textures...just couldn't decide if I should go with the quilted patent or the smooth leather and of course I'm sticking with black (not very daring, I'm afraid :worried: ).

 

[Irissy]

I like the second bag because it looks classier than the first bag. The first bag looks a bit boring to me.

 

[mellyjr]

I like the quilted bag. Where do you live in Northern California? I live in San Jose.

 

[jasanna143]

Definitely the second! Even better IRL!

 

[PurseSlave]

Quilted! It's not so plain, like the first one.

 

[mello_yello_jen]

quilted =)

 

[BorsaBella]

Black quilted!!!!!!

 

[Mshashmount]

i think the black one's prettyyy...