If you had to choose?

Which one, and why?


  • Total voters
    37

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

May 2, 2011
881
1,040
I am so torn on which to choose!

I love both but if i could only choose one! Which one?!

I love the onyx as it looks nice and a bit masculine on a guy.

But i love all white gold!

I do live in Hawaii and occasionally want to go swim in the ocean or pool and heard onyx could tolerate but I’m not sure?!

Any thoughts or opinions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4574.jpeg
    IMG_4574.jpeg
    72.5 KB · Views: 11
  • IMG_4573.jpeg
    IMG_4573.jpeg
    66 KB · Views: 11
  • Like
Reactions: hhw and china_doll
I am so torn on which to choose!

I love both but if i could only choose one! Which one?!

I love the onyx as it looks nice and a bit masculine on a guy.

But i love all white gold!

I do live in Hawaii and occasionally want to go swim in the ocean or pool and heard onyx could tolerate but I’m not sure?!

Any thoughts or opinions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
My DH was in the same boat as you but ultimately went with the white gold guilloché in your photo! The shine on that is just so pretty :love: our SA mentioned scratches can show easily on this but he wears it frequently and so far so good!

We both don't have any onyx but I know people who do and shower with it. I did hear that going into pools can cause the onyx to lose its lustre due to the chemicals so I would be careful there.

Have you tried both on in person? I may be bias but when DH tried on the guilloché in-person, he was sold🤭
 
If most of your jewelry is YG, go for YG. My mom wears her onyx all the time. 24/7. It’s in really good shape and the gold is still very shiny. If you’ve got mostly WG, and don’t mind scratches, then WG guilloche. However if you are branching out to start a new collection in either gold then go for either. Sorry I’m no help.
 
I voted WG Guilloche not only because it sparkles but I would pick all pure gold ✨️ over stones anytime! It's worry free n suited for swim 🏊‍♀️ Also with yearly price increase, always buy the expensive ones 1st. You can always get Onyx later as they're most of the time available compared to Guilloche.
 
  • Love
Reactions: CartierLVer
I voted WG Guilloche not only because it sparkles but I would pick all pure gold ✨️ over stones anytime! It's worry free n suited for swim 🏊‍♀️ Also with yearly price increase, always buy the expensive ones 1st. You can always get Onyx later as they're most of the time available compared to Guilloche.
I really like the idea! Thank you! 🥰
 
Top