if you had to choose between a metallic pink & an 05 BG pink...

  1. which would you choose?

    they're both $600. i won the metallic pink but since i had an issue with a korean buyer that froze my eBay funds...i haven't been able to pay the seller (see my eBay thread)

    i really like the BG pink and got a 2nd offer...i can get both but think i should only pick ONE and am going with the metallic pink since it's more 'rare' and i really like the box. hope i'm making the right decision!

    they're both from 05. this will be my 3rd box. i have the 06 rose and 05 magenta box.

    pics from eBay
    8a35_12.JPG b5f4_12.JPG
  2. I like the Metallic Pink Box! That's my vote ;)
  3. Metallic Pink is my choice as well!
  4. I would go for metallic pink too.
  5. Guess I'm going to be in the minority, but i am not a big fan of the metallics. But I think the 05 BG is gorgeous. And I'm also partial to the day style.
  6. BG!

  7. ITA. The BG is lovely!
  8. I'm not a fan of the metallics too, so definitely BG Pink!
  9. I choose the metallic pink..
  10. If you won the auction for the Box, don't you HAVE TO take that one?:graucho:
  11. I am not really a pinklover but I agree the BG gets my vote. I think you will not tire as quickly of the BG as of a metallic one but that's just me.
  12. I'm not a fan of metallic bags, so I'd go for the 05 BG pink.
  13. I love the 05 BG day! :love:
  14. I think metallic will go out of style eventually and a pretty and soft pink like the 05 BG is a little more timeless and rich looking.
  15. I agree!!!
    The metallic leather is also NOT durable while BG Pink is from 2005 .. the leather is really thick and smooth

    So, my vote is BG PINK!!! Great price too!!! Go for it :tup: