If you had the choice between these 2 rings...

[sweetgumtree]

which would you choose?

I have a engagement ring and wedding ring that I have never really liked. My H has told me that I can chose between a 1.90 carat H VS2 RBC set in plat with .30 tcw baguettes OR the TIffany Legacy aquamarine ring. I love both these rings! Which would you choose?

 

[sweetgumtree]

resources.shopstyle.com/pim/2d/a6/2da6c857acba50bb0776d5fdc8de6d27_medium.jpg

I can't find a picture of the diamond ring

Never mind I don't know how to post pictures.

 

[Nieners]

Here it is.

 

[annemerrick]

I would go with the diamond. The Tiffany ring is pretty, but I think it is trendy. You could find a less expensive ring that is similar. Diamonds on the other hand never go out of style!

 

[risingsun]

I would prefer an ideal cut diamond as an engagement ring.

 

[Swanky]

diamond

 

[Bagluvluv]

Diamond for me too!!!

 

[sweetgumtree]

Thanks for posting my picture!! And thanks for all the opinions. I was leaning towards the diamond too

 

[shanam]

I don't think you will ever get tired of the traditional diamond.
Ring styles change every few years, but the classic, traditional styles surpass time.

 

[ayla]

Definitely diamond !

 

[ahertz]

no question about it. but what about a diamond set like the legacy?

 

[mjlover1977]

diamond definitely - the other one is pretty but i love the beauty of diamonds for an e-ring.

 

[GnomeNisse]

The diamond! It would never even be a debate in my mind.

 

[oranGetRee]

diamond for me too.

 

[chanel-girl]

Diamond!