If you had the chance, which would you choose?

Which to choose?

  • Brand New Lambskin with GHW

  • Vintage style Lamb with GHW (oversized CC's)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Oniomaniac

Member
Dec 25, 2008
854
16
Hello Ladies,

It's me again. I still haven't been able to decide what my next bag is going to be. I know I asked earlier if it woul dbe worth it to get another black maxi, but instead with lamb and GHW vs. my caviar SHW. Many of you made some great points as to getting another color, but I really love the GHW and lamb combo...:sigh:

So, I thought of something. I have always been obsessed with the vintage flap, the one with the XL interlocking CC's. So what if I try and get one of those instead? Do you think this is a better option than the newer maxi?

I need your help!
 

Rose100

Carpe handbag!
O.G.
Jan 8, 2008
1,507
65
USA
Go for it . Vintage bags are so well made that you may just never buy a new one ever again!
 

shosho811

Reformed Shopaholic
O.G.
Nov 25, 2008
1,360
25
London
I'm the lone one here, I prefer the shape of the new ones over the vintage.

Would like the new ones better made, but, I guess I can't have it all
 

queenofchic

Member
Mar 17, 2008
1,300
3
^ You're not alone. I prefer the new ones too. It's understated. I had a vintage XL jumbo with the large CCs & sold it to buy the new one. No regrets whatsoever.
 

Oniomaniac

Member
Dec 25, 2008
854
16
Wow, I didn't think this many people would prefer the newer style to the old one. Is it just because of the shape?
 

annmac

Imabaghag
I have black maxi lamb ghw and black maxi caviar shw. For me it's two diff bags. I wear the caviar for casual and lamb for something dressier. I love both and most of my Chanel bags are black. Go with the newer version i love the look of it. Whatever makes you happy go with it. :smile:
 

Oniomaniac

Member
Dec 25, 2008
854
16
I'm like that too. I usually always prefer something new vs. something pre-loved, but I'm trying to grow my collection without it being too repetitive...oh goodness.