I need some opinions, PLEASE??

Lol, I love all your comments, thanks so much for your imput...

Practical me says I will reach way more for the duffle...you guys just have to experience wearing one to know how it fits just perfectly..to all those of you who own one, you know what I mean, huh?

The Carly is a lovely color, but how often do we reach for a bag that slips off?

And the satchel is cool, but up on the shoulder one strap stays, one strap flops, and that would drive me batty.

I think the Bleecker is the one to keep, even though it looks huge to some gals, I'm not a skinny minnie, so I think I'll be able to pull it off. lol..
now if they would just do it in some spring colors I could have the best of both worlds..fashion & comfort!

You are all just the best & thanks so much for the great advice & honest opinions!