I did a little shopping yesterday and found these 3 bags at the outlets...but I've pretty much decided against the satchel, since I don't really ever actually use my hand-held bags. It's gorgeous, though and lightweight. The Carly doesn't fit as well on the shoulder as the Bleecker duffle, but it's empty. I was thinking maybe if it had something in it, it would stay put? The Bleecker is a wonderful fit, in Ink, but that Carly is so pretty! Great prices too. The duffle was only $175; the Carly $343, but still better than retail! Any opinions on what I should stick with? Anyone have these bags? Does the Carly strap soften up & fit better with actual use? TIA!!!