I have to let 1 go. edith or paddy?

[asl_bebes]

I voted for the edith. I have a blanc paddie as well and I absolutely love it! I just think the paddie will become a cult classic because it is a very unique design and Chloe's first 'it' bag (I could be wrong about that, pls correct me if I'm wrong). I was never into Chloe bags until I saw the paddie JMO.

 

[winterpearls3]

I think the answer to your problem is:

Keep the Edith, Sell the Paddy

 

[Perja]

I'd say keep the Paddy, sell the Edith. When the fad with school/professor bags is over again, the paddies will have retained value where as the Edith, while a nice bag, isn't going to be all that.

 

[blugenie]

This one is so tough - I agree with both ET and Perja... it would help to know what the rest of your collection is besides these, spy and birkin. Two paddys is a lot if you feel you're done. Edith is a similar shape but so diff from birkin.... hmmm. I cannot bring myself to vote anyone off the island!

 

[ChloeSS]

My collection have
Le fab
LV Josephine
3 pouchette
MJ stam
Chanel 2.55 reissue
fendi spy
Paddy
Birkin
YSL Muse
Edith

 

[blugenie]

Hmmm, what's the color of your other paddy? Still have it? You might chose BJ birkin over blanc paddy every time.

If it's financial, I'd sell spy + one paddy for the best $$ return. Keep one paddy for casual/deconstructed bag, and see how you feel about Edith once you see it too...could use one more casual bag....?

 

[hfxshopgirl]

i'm not an edith fan, so i vote keep the paddy

 

[ChloeSS]

My other paddy is in tan color i sold it already.. so now I only have one blanc paddy..

 

[Kat]

I'd get rid of the Paddy, but I've never really been a fan of that bag.

 

[ETenebris]

I think the Edith has more longevity, since it's less of a "trendy" bag...but this is a tough decision!

 

[abaglover]

I would sell the paddy only because you have another paddy already. And it's always nice to have another tote like the Edith. I love big bags and am always toting everything around with me.

 

[Serenity Now]

Keep the Paddy! You've already sold your tan one so you absolutely need to hold on to this one!!

 

[monotreme]

if you are letting the edith go, please PM me!

 

[BalenciagaLove]

Have the decision been made now?? I got lost!! Keep the Edith, sell the paddy, unless you've already sold the paddy you were going to sell!

 

[blugenie]

BL I think Edith hadn't arrived yet when the poll went out... waiting for pics, pics!