You know, initially I loved the ergo totes (sitting on the shelf), so I bought the large Vachetta one in the natural color. However, when I removed the packing materials and started to carry it one day, I realized I did not like the look on my shoulder. It dips kind of ugly at the bottom unless you have it majorly stuffed (my opinion here), and I don't like the look while wearing it. So I sold it and was very happy I did so. Perhaps the smaller totes are better because they are not as deep...don't know. Anyway, I recommend you try the bags without the packing materials and with your own contents (
Coach SAs are more than happy to help you do this). That way you can see which one feels and looks great, and you can probably make an easier decision. I wish I had done that from the beginning, because it would have definitely saved me some disapointment!