sight unseen and now I have to make my decision which one to keep. I want to return one tomorrow and get it over with, but I'm awful at decisions. The leathers are completely different and even the colors are a little different. The Day is very thick, smooshy, a tiny bit shiny, distressed with no veins. The City is thinner leather, very very shiny, kind of crinkly (but not dry) a little bit veiny. I think I'm leaning towards the Day. Just curious which leather do you prefer, I know it's impossible to tell from the pics I just took with flash tonight.