Hello all I saw the Legacy Ali bag last Saturday and fell in love. I knew I would own this bag - the only issue was the color. I narrowed my choices down to the black leather, whiskey leather, and charcoal suede. After two days, I eliminated the suede - I feared maintenance issues. Today, one of my co-workers showed up with the whiskey, with the matching wallet. She loved them. After seeing hers, and hearing her glowing reviews, I decided that whiskey would be my final choice. However, when I arrived at the Coach store, my SA informed me that the bag was prone to scuffing, but that added to its charm. I know myself, I would be crazed with a scuffed up $500.00 bag. So in the end, I went with the black. The whiskey is TDF, but the black is gorgeous and won't be as high maintenance as the others. I am so happy that Coach has introduced this line.