Howard St Satchel - Black or Magenta or BOTH?

Which Howard St Satchel?

  • Black

  • Magenta

  • BOTH?


Results are only viewable after voting.

pinkboudoir

♥
May 19, 2006
8,267
8
SUN-shine-y island
I have never owned a Botkier. No thanks to the gorgeous Howard St Satchel pictures I see everywere, I am now drawn to this cute bag. Now...I cannot decide between these 2 colours. Black OR Magenta. I am sure I love Magenta but the pebbled black leather xlana has is just TDF. Would getting both be too much? Or are they completely different look that I need?
 

Cloud5

Member
Jan 3, 2010
1,090
0
Hi pink...nice seeing you here! Personally I am a one bag one color kind of girl so it is hard for me to buy multiple colors of the same bag. If I didn't get cement I would have the black in my hand right now. I like the pebbled leather on the bag. Either way I don't think you can go wrong! :smile:
 

pinkboudoir

♥
May 19, 2006
8,267
8
SUN-shine-y island
Thanks to your pics, I came here. You are such bad company(OK I am weak LOL). Your Cement is TDF & I went on a quest to check the colours available. I love multiples but have recently started to be a one style one colour bag person but that pebbled black is TDF & Magenta is soooo my colour.
 

xlana

O.G.
Sep 26, 2006
5,949
556
New York City
I think it really depends on what color bag you need at the moment. But for me, I saw the Howard St. as an edgier bag, and so I opted for the black! It's a gorgeous bag!! I'm sure you'll love it as much as I do! It was my first Botkier too!
 

pinkboudoir

♥
May 19, 2006
8,267
8
SUN-shine-y island
I have 4 Black bags now & I seldom wear black bags but like you, I like the edgy-ness of the Black Howard St. I definitely want Magenta...blk would be the second bag if I get it.
 

Cloud5

Member
Jan 3, 2010
1,090
0
If you have 4 black bags than I think magenta would be the better choice! :tup:
 

starkfan

O.G.
Jan 18, 2009
3,623
677
Nice to see you over here contemplating a Botkier, pb! ;) If you're still looking for a pink bag, yep, Magenta definitely sounds like it'd be a great possibility... I think it's a lambskin too (though possibly slightly glazed), and Botkier's lambskins are TDF!
 

tejava

O.G.
Jun 30, 2008
2,798
92
Maybe magenta is what you normally prefer, but for some reason I feel you are attracted to the black, that's why you can't give up completely.

I don't think I am helping here. Maybe you can get either one first and see how you like the style/leather, I think being able to see and touch a bag in real life would totally change what you feel about a bag or style. If you find yourself liking the style, then get the other color as well.
 
Last edited:

zoesma

NICE KITTY
Jan 22, 2009
4,395
0
New York
pink!!! you are here too!!! i am also looking at the logan vs the howard....i am not sure which one to get....and knowing how you love pink i would say magenta!!!
 

zoesma

NICE KITTY
Jan 22, 2009
4,395
0
New York
yay pink!!! that magenta looks BEAUTIFUL!!! if i didnt have the treesje asher i would be all over that one too!!