I got my first BBag, a City Café, in March 2007 so I'm not one of those "die hard" chevre fans. I love the leather on that, but I also really love the leather on my 2008 bags, it does seem more thick and way more even than my 06 First. At first I was disappointed that it was going to be agneau instead of chevre, but I totally love my agneau bags. I guess it's a matter of taste. Oh, and btw go to Paris to get your black City! You'll save so much money and probably have lots more bags to choose from!