Shopmom, I have a SO (my only SO) black crinolin/black barenia 35 cm Birkin. I adore this bag...I love the look of crinolin and Barenia is my favorite leather. The bag is light as it is lined in fabric and not leather. That said...I do think that the crinolin is more fragile than the usual textured leathers, and yes, it has a few broken ends that are not very noticeable...I don't really know how it will hold up with time, but I suspect it is not refurbishable and I doubt it will have the longevity of the all-leather bags, if subjected to the same wear and tear...now I am not trying to discourage you in any way, and I (obviously) wanted this combo badly enough to SO it when I had but a moment to decide when the opportunity presented itself, unexpectedly...and I am not sorry...it's a very special bag.