Horrible Nordstrom Experience

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Colletteardith

New Member
Dec 2, 2018
2
0
The day before Thanksgiving, I decided to finally splurge on a bag I've been eyeing at Nordstrom- the Heroine 30 Alexander McQueen Black Croc-Embossed tote. When it arrived, it was gorgeous, perfectly packaged, and I was so excited. About a week later, Nordstrom released their 10 point promo, so I figured what's the harm in calling to see if they can apply it to my purchase. So I called, they said they couldn't, but that I could repurchase the item and return what I bought already. Because I was out and about anyways, I figured I'd go ahead and return the first purse I got so I could get that off of my to-do list (in hindsight, I really should have just taken it to the store and asked them to return then let me repurchase it). It turned out that the 10 point promo only applies when you use your Nordstrom Credit Card, which I didn't want to do. This was partly my fault for misreading the fine print for the promo. A few days later, my new bag arrived.... wrapped in a plastic bag, with no dust bag, and no official box- and to add a cherry on top, there were scuffs all over the hardware. This bag was clearly used and returned, and Nordstrom felt it was appropriate to send this item back out as a new item. I was livid. The bag then sold out, so I couldn't exchange it, and their customer service manager on the phone told me I could either return the bag or exchange it for something else. She didn't offer any sort of consolation or solution that I couldn't figure out myself. I asked her to explain why they found it appropriate to send out used and damaged merchandise- especially designer purchases, and she had no explanation, and simply blamed everything on the distributors. I gave up on the phone call because it was getting me nowhere, and found that later that night, the bag was back in stock, so I immediately purchased it, and found the mini version at Saks off Fifth. I figured I'd compare how both of the bags arrived, and make a decision on which to keep afterwards. The bag sold out again after I bought it, then showed up online again the next morning in stock again. Two days later, I get an email that my order can't be fulfilled because it is out of stock, and now I'm extremely nervous that the Saks off Fifth bag is going to come in this same, horrible condition, and without a dust bag or official box. I had a little bit of trouble returning the damaged bag because there was nothing at that point to authenticate the bag at all, and it was also damaged. I wanted to know if anyone has had this type of experience with Nordstrom before, and if Saks off Fifth is a legitimate place to purchase an Alexander McQueen bag from. I don't mean to come off as spoiled by any means, I just had a bad week to begin with, and on top of that this was my very first major luxury handbag purchase, and it's been nothing but a waste of time and honestly discouraging, especially since I love Nordstrom.
 
Sounds like an error in the return department, where you were sent a bag that should have been returned to the manufacturer. The lack of dust bag and box really makes me think they stuck it in your box by mistake. An unfortunate downside to Nordstrom's website is that, at this time of year, their information on what's in stock isn't always accurate. It's not unusual in December for something to sell out before the program recognizes it, and the constant marking of something be in stock then out of stock either tells me a glitch in the system or a lot of people buying the product then immediately cancelling the order, or their credit card refusing the transaction.

Sorry all this happened, it's not the norm, I think it was a case of simple human error during the busiest retail month of the year. Best option is to contact your local store and see if they have the bag or not. Concerning Saks Off Fifth: it's always been a crapshoot for me. I've had better luck with them online, my local store seems to never have more than three people working at once, handbag section has product everywhere like a Walmart, etc.
 
Sounds like an error in the return department, where you were sent a bag that should have been returned to the manufacturer. The lack of dust bag and box really makes me think they stuck it in your box by mistake. An unfortunate downside to Nordstrom's website is that, at this time of year, their information on what's in stock isn't always accurate. It's not unusual in December for something to sell out before the program recognizes it, and the constant marking of something be in stock then out of stock either tells me a glitch in the system or a lot of people buying the product then immediately cancelling the order, or their credit card refusing the transaction.

Sorry all this happened, it's not the norm, I think it was a case of simple human error during the busiest retail month of the year. Best option is to contact your local store and see if they have the bag or not. Concerning Saks Off Fifth: it's always been a crapshoot for me. I've had better luck with them online, my local store seems to never have more than three people working at once, handbag section has product everywhere like a Walmart, etc.


I called Saks yesterday and they informed me that this bag is an online only item. Funny enough, I think if you even try to look it up directly on their site, it doesn't pop up. I actually found the link on their page via a google search with the name of the bag. I'm just concerned that this new mini one might possibly be made specifically for outlets- although I can't bring myself to believe that Alexander McQueen would be a company to do that.
 
I Have had NUMEROUS issues with Nordstrom. They have quite a history of accepting clearly used items as normal returns and then shipping them to other customers. This happens too many times to be considered errors by shipping dept. Anyway, here are my top 3 Nordstrom No-No's :

2015
I purchased a pair of Hunter wellie socks that were on sale on Nordstrom online. I received socks in a torn hunter box just balled up inside. Socks were clearly used, smelled like feet and covered in cat hair. I called to complain and was told to send them back or take them into a Nordstrom store to return. I told the woman on the phone that I wouldn't date take them to a store as it would be embarrassing. I mailed them back.

2016
I called Nordstrom to inquire about a Celine handbag and the SA on the phone told me they just got a brand new one and had the bag on display. She agreed to hold it for me and I rushed to the store. It was beautiful and the exterior looked untouched. Imagine my shock when she took the stuffing out of the bag and in the zipper compartment was a pen, a quarter and a grocery list. Upon further examination, the interior of the bag was quite dirty and the dustbag was dirty and had a mint stuck to it. On this occasion I could not do anything but laugh that they were actually trying to sell me a CLEARLY used bag. When the manager was called, she was very dismissive about the issue and said nothing she could do. She was probably the one who approved the return. I was thankful that I did not do a charge/send and quickly left the store.

2017
I ordered a pair of black patent Gucci shoes on sale from Nordstrom online. I received a pair of brown Gucci slides that were at least 5 seasons old (Nordstrom did not even carry Gucci then) in the old style brown box with all of the stickers removed. They were at least new. I called immediately to complain and the person on the phone was apologetic. She agreed with me that someone ordered the new shoes and then brought their old shoes back as if they were returning the new ones and someone just accepted the return. Again, I did not return these to the store because I refused to waste any gas and time on their nonsense. On this occasion, I sent a letter to Nordstrom Corporate along with receipts and pictures of everything. They could not even bother to respond. In the letter I stated that it was most certainly Nordstrom's prerogative to accept a switch/theft from a customer. It was however unacceptable to pass the misfortune on to another unsuspecting customer. I am sure they did not like that.
 
Nordstrom is skating on their former reputation of excellent customer service. It hasn’t been that way in YEARS.

Eventually the current experiences and stories like these will eclipse the former folk lore of the Nordstrom employee who took back a set of tires and they will have to evaluate their standards against the likes of Zappos who truly do excel at customer service.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eleanors36
Nordstrom is playing games and it’s irritating AF

I’ve ordered a pair of theory pants THREE TIMES since Saturday at 60% off as a price match. Each time they were cancelled within 24 hours due to lack of inventory. Obviously they came back in stock because I was able to order them two more times... Just now they’re back in stock in my size, but at regular MSRP. Something’s not right.
 
Just received this today. I’m not even surprised anymore. The top is a hundred dollar sweater. The bottom, a four hundred dollar Longchamp. Get it together Nordstrom.
View attachment 4313248 View attachment 4313249

That is absolutely shameful. Those items are clearly used and/or defective. They have insulted me with their used merchandise and blatant screwups too many times. I refuse to deal with them anymore.
 
Agreed. I too have had many issues. Mostly those are with a personal shopper and their credit card. I finally gave up using my Nordstrom card and purchase only with my card that I receive cash rewards. Win/win. I feel that their merchandise and marketing is nowhere near what it was in the days of yore. Nordstrom is no longer my first choice for shopping. Also their shipping times are slower than many.
 
Top