Hmmmm Givenchy Antigona vs. Cerf Tote

[Td15xx]

Okay TPFers,

Need your help. I posted previously a photo of my Chanel Cerf tote with silver hardware which in stunning, BUT I made the mistake of walking into Barneys and came across
This beauty, I can't decide and now I am conflicted. 😩
Please help me decide on the perfect bag that fits my body type best!

Givenchy Antigona Medium

Or

Chanel Cerf

Please Vote!

Thanks so much xo.

 

[Td15xx]

Cerf tote on me for reference

 

[skyqueen]

Both gorgeous! I think I like the Givenchy better!

 

[Mariapia]

Both are great bags but I prefer the Antigona too.

 

[lmdebutante]

Both are nice but I actually prefer the Cerf.

 

[Eva1991]

I prefer the Cerf.

 

[kuriso]

I love the cerf!

 

[catsinthebag]

Because the photos show the bags being held differently, it's hard to judge your question re. body type. But just comparing bags, I prefer the Cerf. More classic, and the Antigona is too stiff for me.

 

[papertiger]

I voted Cerf too, one of the most underrated, classic bags Chanel makes IMHO

 

[gail13]

Cerf seems much more user friendly-the Antigona just seems like another bag to me and I don't find it comfortable although I have only just 'tried it on'.

 

[Td15xx]

Another photo of the cerf

 

[catsinthebag]

Another photo of the cerf

Looks great on you IMO!

 

[Prettyvogue]

Antigona if you are looking for edgy, very for a more classic or traditional look

 

[Designerhbgirl]

Between the two I like the Antigona better. It's more modern and less formal IMO.

 

[amadea88]

The cerf!