Hi everyone, I'm back to update and give a closure to this post.
It was stressful at the beginning. I tried to call for two days but couldn't get hold of anyone(the first day was busy; the second day, neither my SS nor the director was at the store). Then I emailed my SS and told her I don't what the bag to be repaired, either sent me a new bag or store credits or refund. She said she sent the request to Paris, it had to be decided by them. The store didn't have the authorization. What?! I had no choice but wait. Another week passed by, still no answer. I emailed her again and told her it's too slow and unacceptable. I didn't understand why it took so long to answer a simple question. It was not hard to tell if this bag was authentic or if it was damaged purposely by me. It had been two whole weeks! So I expressed my frustration and told her if I don't get the answer the next day, I will dispute. I had already talked to my credit card company. They could dispute the charge anytime. She forwarded my email to the store director. He emailed me back right away saying the same thing, had to wait for Paris to make the decision. I replied him back and told him my decision was firm, dispute if no answer by the end of business hour tomorrow. The next day around 1pm, viola, got the email from him telling me store credits had been issued. How magical!
I refused a new bag when the director offered. I'm taking a break from Hermes handbags, definitely not a Lindy. I'm a little bit traumatized. But I'm still a sucker for their Birkin and Kelly (fingers crossed for their quality). So maybe I'll use the credits for their other products to build up a profile.
Thanks everyone for your advice. They really helped me. I can't express how much I appreciate them. I hope my experience can also help someone else in the future. One thing I have to admit, their in-person customer service is beyond expectation. I really like my SS. That's actually one of the reasons I didn't ask for a refund but store credits. I like shopping with her assistance. I do most of my shopping online nowadays, so going to the Hermes store is like a special treat.
Just added a profile picture, in the memory of a short-lived, sweet and bitter, my first Hermes bag.
Case closed. =)