Okay, I am in a Coach predicament.. go figure I have purchased the Carly several times in different colors, etc and always end up returning or selling for different reasons.. squeaky, sloppy, etc. I hate to love or love to hate that bag.. I always want it and I can never get it out of my mind!!!! I had a Chelsea large hobo that I loved and it had a couple of stitches coming out of the bottom.. took it into Coach they said no problem, it would be fixed easy... just called (it's been about a month) and they informed me my bag was not fixable and I have a credit for the price of that bag with tax. ($316.63) So, I was kind of bummed but then thought why should I be because I can still order the same bag brand new OR get something else.. like a Carly... and they said I dont' have to wait for the letter, so the even better thing is I can use it during pce!!! So.. question is, should I get the Chelsea again or should I go for it and get a Carly? The colors I am considering are chocolate siggy, khaki/black siggy, or khaki/chocolate siggy. :shrug: Thanks so much for all your help!!!