Help!!! Which red flap should I keep???

[BellaBaby]

Hi!

I need everyone's opinion. I presold 2 red flaps but am going to cancel one (I cannot justify getting both unfortunately). Which one should I keep?

Red Perforated East/West Flap SS07 (picture borrowed from Chanel Reference Library):

or

dark red e/w madison flap spring 2008 (pic borrowed from Chanel Reference Library)




I am leaning toward keeping the Madison but I would love to hear your thoughts.

Thanks so much!!!

 

[Aurora]

Not a fan of the peforated bags. Keep the madison, it's gorgeous

 

[bretiny]

I don't like perforated leather, so my vote goes to the Madison. Is the Madison a bit more expensive? Or are they the same price?

 

[BellaBaby]

Thanks for your opinions!!! I really appreciate it! I am 99% sure I am going to keep the Madison. There is a price difference--the Madison is I think about $300 more but still, I think it is probably worth it. One big concern that I have with the red perfo is that I have heard the red is very orangy (haven't seen it IRL) which I am not thrilled with. Sigh!!!

 

[Savannah]

madison, hot bag.

 

[sjunky13]

I love the red on the madison, it is a more blue based, gorgeous!

 

[BellaBaby]

Thanks all for confirming my gut instinct!

 

[kimalee]

I prefer the perforated!

 

[HappyAngel]

Madison for sure!! It just stands out too much! Love it

 

[DD101]

I like the Madison better, I love the chain detail all around it.

 

[BellaBaby]

Thanks again everyone for all of your thoughts! I really appreciate it!

 

[Tinkerbell2]

I like the Madison much more!! That bag is gorgeous in red..

 

[disturbedgirl]

Both bags are amazing, but I love the Madison. If you're keeping just one, keep that one!!

 

[BellaBaby]

Thanks again for everyone's opinion! I ended up keeping the madison and another TPFer got the red perfo I cancelled so everyone is happy! Yay!!!

 

[wen1987]

i say keep the madison