Everyone's saying Carly, and I agree, but not simply "because." I have 2 pouches, and while they're cute, they're sort of useless if you ask me. I take them to parties because they're not overly precious to me, but I always wind up having to push them back on my shoulder after they slip off. The Carly pouch is a slightly different shape, and really has more of a solid handbag look/feel to it. I think it's much more of an outfit-maker...as for other options, haven't browsed coach.com yet, but of those two, definitely the Carly.