Help!!! which one should i get?

[ice0degree]

Hi ladies,

i'm currently torn between these 2 bags - medium caviar with wood panelling or jumbo kelly. i know both are completely different in style but i'm trying to control my spending, hence will buy only 1

what do you think? i need some advice.

TIA.

BTW: can anyone help me to identify the medium caviar with wood panelling? what is the name of that bag and the retail price? i think its from 2002 or 2003?

 

[kylienarak]

From these 2 choices, I would get the Kelly. Not rly liking the wood part on the classic flap...jmho

 

[lady70113]

My vote is for the kelly.. Very Jackie O n chic... Not lovin wood on a purse

 

[Jaded81]

I prefer the kelly

 

[tastefashion]

vote for kelly, she's too gorgeous to sitting there...

I don't like the wood thing on the flap too.

 

[dannkat]

Kelly gets my vote good luck.

 

[n2chanel]

I would take the kelly for sure.

 

[Winiebean]

another for the kelly

 

[diera23]

kelly

 

[Mediana]

Kelly for me but I have to say, I've never seen a flap with wood panel before. Pretty rare.

 

[thegraceful1]

hmmm...I find the wood panel a litlte bit too odd, therefore the kelly gets my vote.

 

[ice0degree]

thanks everyone for your advice. looks like the kelly wins hands down. I really like the kelly too but i just thought that the wood one is pretty rare and if i miss this one, i might never find again. but after reading all your posts, think i'll go for the kelly as well. i'm so glad i i posted here cuz it makes my decision much easier.

thank you once again.

 

[sweetie_sg]

another vote for Kelly

 

[erinrose]

Definitely kelly, the wooden flap just don´t do it for me. And I think the kelly will do better in the long run!

 

[BAL_Fanatic]

Kelly gets my vote! Love this style!