Help which color?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

snibor

O.G.
Nov 12, 2006
10,834
21,792
I love the saddle 23 bags but unsure of which color. I like black but I already have several black bags. It’s between the gray and saddle color will post pics below. I wear a lot of gray in winter. I already have an older gray shoulder bag I still use from Rebecca minkoff. Which would be more versatile? I’m thinking saddle color is all year round and while a lot of my winter wardrobe is gray, summer is different. Which would I get more use of or are both neutrals? In terms of Browns, I already have Damier ebene bags and a dark brown bag. I have not seen the saddle color in person. Sigh.
Help.
Edit... the other option is neither cauz I don’t really need it. Ha!

IMG_5088.jpg
IMG_5089.jpg
 
Last edited:
I love the saddle 23 bags but unsure of which color. I like black but I already have several black bags. It’s between the gray and saddle color will post pics below. I wear a lot of gray in winter. I already have an older gray shoulder bag I still use from Rebecca minkoff. Which would be more versatile? I’m thinking saddle color is all year round and while a lot of my winter wardrobe is gray, summer is different. Which would I get more use of or are both neutrals? In terms of Browns, I already have Damier ebene bags and a dark brown bag. I have not seen the saddle color in person. Sigh.
Help.
Edit... the other option is neither cauz I don’t really need it. Ha!

View attachment 4244812
View attachment 4244813
That depends upon the colors of clothing you wear. If you wear a lot of bright colors, black, and white, then the gray would work best for you. However, if you wear a lot of neutral colors, like tans, beiges, olives, creams, and browns, then the saddle color would be the one for you. Both are lovely, although I agree with Fayden that the saddle color is the more traditional choice for this bag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: snibor
That depends upon the colors of clothing you wear. If you wear a lot of bright colors, black, and white, then the gray would work best for you. However, if you wear a lot of neutral colors, like tans, beiges, olives, creams, and browns, then the saddle color would be the one for you. Both are lovely, although I agree with Fayden that the saddle color is the more traditional choice for this bag.

Hmm. I think I like the saddle color best. It’s quite striking. But probably have less to wear with it. But it is quite striking. Ugh.
 
It almost reminds me of Hermes “gold” color. I haven’t bought a coach bag in probably 30 years. I like the classic styling of this. Plus you can wear it different ways.

The saddle is a much more classic color, this gray seems more like a fashion for this year but not a long term classic. I think the gray looks better on a small bag (like the phone crossbody) or in combination with other colors (i have the tea rose wristlet in this color and the addition of the flowers makes a big difference-at least to me :smile:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: snibor
The saddle is a much more classic color, this gray seems more like a fashion for this year but not a long term classic. I think the gray looks better on a small bag (like the phone crossbody) or in combination with other colors (i have the tea rose wristlet in this color and the addition of the flowers makes a big difference-at least to me :smile:)

Saddle it is! Thanks everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teagaggle
Top