Help! Used Loving My Bags Bye Bye Dye on Pre-Loved Flap...

[Iheartbags4ever]

I just bought a pre-loved Flap (I think it’s aged calfskin) and on my first use I got dark denim stains on it. I used Loving My Bags Bye Bye Dye on it and while it did remove some of it the cleanser ruined the natural sheen of the leather! Not sure what to do and would love some advice.
On the pic you will see the difference between the left side (where cleanser was used) and the right side (natural shimmer of leather).

Thanks in advance for any thoughts!

 

[WillWork4Fashion]

Next apply the product they sell which adds the sheen back in, and also seals the leather. I forget what it’s called. Their products are amazing! Don’t worry - the next step will fix this.
Update: Use either the “most delicate moisturizer” or, if you want a lot more shine, the “beauty & shine moisturizer.” I always use the most delicate to seal new bags. If your leather is super dull now, I might try the shine moisturizer. Good luck!

 

[Iheartbags4ever]

Next apply the product they sell which adds the sheen back in, and also seals the leather. I forget what it’s called. Their products are amazing! Don’t worry - the next step will fix this.
Update: Use either the “most delicate moisturizer” or, if you want a lot more shine, the “beauty & shine moisturizer.” I always use the most delicate to seal new bags. If your leather is super dull now, I might try the shine moisturizer. Good luck!

Thanks so much! Didn’t know if it would be making a problem worse by adding ANOTHER LMB product...