Help Please ….Which Keepall XS would you choose?

[NatsumiYuki]

If you all had to choose between the Watercolor Ink vs Watercolor Canvas Keepall XS, which would you choose and why.

I have the chance for my SA to help me order one of the above mentioned bags but I am torn on which to choose.

I would like to hear your opinions on both bags and which would you choose.

Thank in advance

 

[MariaB]

Both bags are stunning I had seen neither bag IRL, but I bought the Watercolor Ink because:

- it is an all leather bag, I prefer leather over canvas
- I like the print better, it is very visually pleasing to me
- no risk of color transfer. I wear a lot of dark jeans and greys and blacks and a light canvas bag bag would be an issue for me
- the color/print better suits my wardrobe/style better
- the print/LV-logo is a bit more low-key

They are both very beautiful bags, and the best would be if you could have both bags in front of you and try them on, and then make a choice...however try and watch some YT - there are many unboxings of both bags

I am very, very happy with my Watercolor Ink, but it is a personal preference

 

[NatsumiYuki]

Both bags are stunning I had seen neither bag IRL, but I bought the Watercolor Ink because:

- it is an all leather bag, I prefer leather over canvas
- I like the print better, it is very visually pleasing to me
- no risk of color transfer. I wear a lot of dark jeans and greys and blacks and a light canvas bag bag would be an issue for me
- the color/print better suits my wardrobe/style better
- the print/LV-logo is a bit more low-key

They are both very beautiful bags, and the best would be if you could have both bags in front of you and try them on, and then make a choice...however try and watch some YT - there are many unboxings of both bags

I am very, very happy with my Watercolor Ink, but it is a personal preference

Thank you for taking your time to reply to my post I appreciate it! You have raised up quite a few points that I agree with!

With the watercolor ink Keepall XS, I am just worried on whether it will lose it’s shape and develop creases on the leather. As well as not being able to carry it when it’s raining.

My main concern with the watercolor canvas is the possibility of color transfer. But I feel that this print is more low key as the LV monorgram on this piece looks like a faded gray ( never seen both IRL, going off the website’s photo).

 

[23adeline]

I have both, the Ink is my first Keepall xs , I love the size and the look of keepall xs .
Among the 2, I actually like the canvas one more, especially the back of it It is like watercolor painting .

 

[NatsumiYuki]

I have both, the Ink is my first Keepall xs , I love the size and the look of keepall xs .
Among the 2, I actually like the canvas one more, especially the back of it It is like watercolor painting .View attachment 5235970
View attachment 5235972View attachment 5235971View attachment 5235973

I also love the back of the Watercolor Canvas! I feel like it’s more low key! I’m just worried in regards to color transfer.
Do you think spraying the whole bag with colloni carbon pro with help prevent that!

I do love how the leather looks I am just worried in terms of how to care for it.

 

[trunkdevil]

You can’t go wrong with either I own both and love them. Personally find Ink easier to wear and love leather but the white watercolor canvas is very pretty/unique.

 

[balen.girl]

I have the leather one and it’s worry free. So far the shape is good, really no issues with the bag.

 

[NatsumiYuki]

You can’t go wrong with either I own both and love them. Personally find Ink easier to wear and love leather but the white watercolor canvas is very pretty/unique.

Another thing I’m worried about with the Watercolor Ink is it getting wet when it rains, as the weather can be unpredictable in where I am. It can be sunny one minute and suddenly be raining the next minute

 

[NatsumiYuki]

I have the leather one and it’s worry free. So far the shape is good, really no issues with the bag.
View attachment 5236053

Looks good! And love the charm you have on it. Do you happen to use an organiser with this bag? And do you think it’s more carefree than the WC canvas in terms of care?

Sorry for all the questions as I have never had an all leather bag before.

 

[balen.girl]

Looks good! And love the charm you have on it. Do you happen to use an organiser with this bag? And do you think it’s more carefree than the WC canvas in terms of care?

Sorry for all the questions as I have never had an all leather bah before.

Thank you. It’s an old charm which I kept for long and never had the chance to use because of silver hardware and non of my bag are silver. So I am so happy with this bag, I can finally use my charm.
I didn’t use bag organizer because the bag is small and I don’t think I need organizer. So far so good, the leather stay the same, not slouch or something. I think the leather one is worry free compare to canvas ink because the color is darker. I always use this bag with my jeans. No issues so far. Good luck on deciding.

 

[NatsumiYuki]

Thank you. It’s an old charm which I kept for long and never had the chance to use because of silver hardware and non of my bag are silver. So I am so happy with this bag, I can finally use my charm.
I didn’t use bag organizer because the bag is small and I don’t think I need organizer. So far so good, the leather stay the same, not slouch or something. I think the leather one is worry free compare to canvas ink because the color is darker. I always use this bag with my jeans. No issues so far. Good luck on deciding.

Thank you

 

[bagsamplified]

I love lighter coloured bags in the watercolor, I find the watercolor Ink too serious for me. But that's my personal taste.
I am like you and live in unpredictable weather. I don't own a Canvas yet but I read in another thread someone bought the Keepall XS in Sunset canvas and it suited the humid weather really well. That is making me lean towards something in the range.

 

[Tigerlily1]

I have both and like the watercolor canvas more. I think it’s more unique and beautiful IRL.
I’m not too worried about colour transfer cause it’s not uniformly coloured anyway.
That said, both bags are great!!