Help pick a new bag: YSL or McQueen?

[LaLafashionista]

Hi ladies,

I posted the same thread in Saint Laurent's forum, thought I'd post here as well since there's no MaCqeen forum.

I'm looking at some duffle bag and now come to two choices. One is Saint Lautent Ligne Y Petit Cabas, the other is Alexander McQueen Small Padlock. Here are the links:

http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/alexande...resultback=317

http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/saint-la...esultback=2428

I have neither experience with both McQeen and Saint Laurent ( used to buy the old YSL though), so please share your opinions. Is the leather easy to take are of? How's the weight? Color fading issues?

Thank you for your time.

 

[LaLafashionista]

Waiting for feedbacks....

 

[applecidered]

I don't think your links work... aside from that, after a quick google I like the look of both bags! I think it comes down to your personal preference. I'm not the biggest fan of this particular YSL logo (I like the more traditional YSL one vs the Y only), so between the two I would pick the Mcqueen.

 

[Puttin On Ayers]

Saint Laurent Y ligne cabas is a gorgeous handbag

 

[amadea88]

Agree with above poster, love the YSL.

 

[LaLafashionista]

Thank you for your feedbacks.

 

[frzsri]

The McQ, as SL cabas is quite a bit heavier.

 

[Waffle65]

I like the Saint Laurent better. I prefer the shape of it to the McQueen.

 

[estrella.bribie]

I love the mcqueen [emoji177][emoji7]