Help!!! Need to Choose between Two 07 Black SGH PTs!

Help Me Choose!!!

  • Bag #1 - Oooey Gooey Broken Agneau

  • Bag #2 - Stiff, Shiny Chevre

  • Neither - hold out for another


Results are only viewable after voting.

brunettetiger

Follow Your Heart...
O.G.
Apr 17, 2007
3,445
8
Fantasy Island
I got the last two 07 black PTs from two different places that just arrived today:yahoo: But...now I have to choose - pls help me make the right choice!

Both 07's but definately different batches.

Bag#1) This is exactly how i would want my black PT to look, feel, behave. Very oooey and gooey and would have been the obvious choice, But...it looks very used which of course makes it look fabulous, but I paid for a new bag and the used aspect may really bother me. Also she is agneau.





Bag#2) Chevre. Brand spanking new. Dark, glossy, but very stiff and almost plastiky. Heavier than #1. Looks like the texture of my RH 07 Fall Black City which broken in nicely, but doesn't have that ooooey goooey-ness that I really wanted my PT SGH to deliver. Will she ever look like Bag #1?




 

Attachments

karenab

O.G.
Mar 16, 2007
4,899
94
If #1 doesn't feel too thin, then I would go with that one.

Its what you ultimately wanted looks wise. Even if its chevre, the feel of #2 being somewhat plastic like would put me right off. Its like you got the bottom of barrell. The left overs. KWIM?

I go with what makes my heart skip a beat.
 

bellini

O.G.
Oct 7, 2007
639
3
i voted for 1. the look is right. i feel like i'm going to be in the minority, but as long as i like the leather, i'm not getting too caught up on the agneau/chevre thing.
 

karenab

O.G.
Mar 16, 2007
4,899
94
Bag 1 is so ooey gooey I could roll her up...but definately not thin
ok then thats great.

I agree with the other pfer. Don't get caught up in the agneau vs. chevre leather thing.

At this point, its what bag grabs you the most - regardless.

I'm sure there is one you are siding with too - no?

I notice bag #1 has feet too! I know that has now been eliminated.
 

brunettetiger

Follow Your Heart...
O.G.
Apr 17, 2007
3,445
8
Fantasy Island
I'm siding with #1, she definately grabbed me. I don't care as much about the agneau, but I do care that it is very used and I paid a new price...would u guys?