Help me pick a boxy bag

[nanads]

Hi beautiful people, I’ve been wanting a ‘boxy’ bag for awhile and after considering for a while it’s between these two, which one would you pick, and why?
Any input will be much appreciated!

 

[lill_canele]

I like both bags but I prefer the celine over the dior one just a little more because I like how the metal piece is a little more centered than the CD of the dior.
The Celine metal logo feels more balanced while the Dior metal logo feels more bottom heavy.

But that just may be me being weird or a personal preference lol.

 

[nycgirl79]

I like both bags but I prefer the celine over the dior one just a little more because I like how the metal piece is a little more centered than the CD of the dior.
The Celine metal logo feels more balanced while the Dior metal logo feels more bottom heavy.

But that just may be me being weird or a personal preference lol.

Totally agree with you on the Dior logo being more bottom heavy. I think both bags are lovely, and despite the chunkier logo, I prefer the Dior. The Celine looks a bit more delicate/flimsy, and a bit dressier. The Dior looks a bit more versatile (dress it up or down) and sturdy to me.

I’m clearly in the minority though, according to your poll, nanads!

 

[Christofle]

The Celine by a country mile!

The Dior one doesn’t feel as cohesive or as well thought out. It feels too much like a committee designed it after looking at the H Constance.