Help me decide please

[cbarber1123]

Okay here is my story....first I went to Coach yesterday and bought the Bone Croc embossed Maggie and I carried her all day yesterday and she was just too heavy and the shoulder strap would not stay on my shoulder so sadly I took her back to Coach to return and I got the glided op art Brooke style no 15002 in Silver/Gray. This bag is gorgeous don't get me wrong but I can't get the Gunmetal Alexandra out of my mind that I tried on also. The leather is to die for. Which bag should I choose?? Should I keep my Brooke or trade her for the Alexandra??

 

[MrsPink82]

My vote is to keep the Brooke. I just feel like it's a more unique bag. Either will be great though!

 

[almabr06]

Alexandra....

 

[Doribelle]

I have the gunmetal Alexandra and LOVE her. She gets my vote!

 

[lov]

I go with brooke.

 

[emilybug]

Alexandra. More versatile. And it's gorgeous!

 

[kirbymax]

Alexandra, she's such a great bag.

 

[princess69]

I just got my gunmetal Alexandra yesterday and unfortunately, I'm returning her. Not "gunmetal-y" enough for me. But I do love the Alexandra style (I already have 2) so she gets my vote.

 

[ejoy43]

I love love love both bags, but I would go with the Alexandra just because that bag has the crossbody option as well as the option to wear on the shoulder or as a satchel. I love versatile bags like that.

 

[cbarber1123]

thanks everyone for your opinions. I will carry Brooke until this weekend and see what I think. I might exchange on Sunday. I will post a pic of what I choose. Thanks again.

 

[dawnqueenb69]

I say keep the Brooke, sounds like a nice color combo, can you post pic.s? The Alexandra's do Nothing for me, I myself Love my Poppy Glam, so really, I'm not too much help,lol...Good Luck on whatever you decide.....

 

[cbarber1123]

My battery in my camera is dead. I will get some tonight and then post some pictures.