Im voting for burnt orange too (even though its not one of your choices!!) I will have the bag in black, so that would have been my first choice, but since you just got a black Ali and its going to be warm out soon, how many black bags do you need right now, right? The patents are pretty but like you I have several patents, and didnt want to have a whole wardrobe of patents. The tan is nice, but you seem to have that covered w/the other ergo, so that leaves the white (I do not like white bags but thats just me!) and the burnt orange. It can be spring-y since its a nice color, but not too "in your face" bright. Its a neutral that works with black/brown/blue/tan/etc plus any nice bright spring colors. If you really dont like the burnt orange, then my next choices would be black or tan, regular leather.