I've got the black one. I wanted the tan but the bag seemed too big and my arm would get lost in there digging to the bottom. I am very happy with the black one being it is a little roomier than it looks. Has a nice depth. Here's pics of mine.
Thanks for all the advice! I ended up getting the smaller black bag - it's not small at all really - the leather is soooo nice and smooshy - I recommend her highly!