Help me decide between these two YG necklaces

[sallyh57i]

Which one of these two yellow gold necklaces would be better for daily wear and to layer other necklaces with?
I mostly wear smart/business casual and prefer dainty necklaces. Just turned 30.

1) Mini Heart Tag Necklace

https://www.tiffany.com/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/return-to-tiffany-mini-heart-tag-pendant-72975154/

View attachment 1000069702.webp
View attachment 1000069699.webp

2) Mini Smile Pendant

https://www.tiffany.com/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/tiffany-t-smile-pendant-63528676/

View attachment 1000069701.webp
View attachment 1000069698.webp

 

[lill_canele]

I feel that the smile pendant is easier to layer with other necklaces due to the curvature of the shape. It is also more of a minimalist piece and more neutral.

The heart is a heart. There's no question about it. The label on the heart is quite small so I feel that it would be fine in any work environment. However, if you want to be really low key, the smile pendant has no label on it what-so-ever.

Tiffany necklaces tend to have very fine chains. Just keep that in mind when you want to layer. If it gets tangled with other chains, it has a higher risk of breaking.
I have a Tiffany DBTY necklaces that I never take off and I've never had issues with the chain breaking or tangling on itself but I also almost never layer it with other necklaces.

 

[880]

Depends on what you want:

The heart is more of a focal point

The smile is more of a supporting piece

I think both could be layered assuming chains don’t tangle. (I don’t know much about dainty Tiffany chains)

 

[lovebug11]

I vote for the smile! More classic & will never look outdated.

 

[Moxisox]

I also prefer the smile.

 

[pinkdewy]

Have you considered the bean necklace?
The smile is nice but in mini size somehow it doesn't resemble a smile so much.
Small size smile can look nicer in proportion.

 

[sallyh57i]

Have you considered the bean necklace?
The smile is nice but in mini size somehow it doesn't resemble a smile so much.
Small size smile can look nicer in proportion.

I'm not a big fan of the bean design. I totally agree that a small size smile looks better! I had the chance to try it on and it looked too big on me though.

 

[Yodabest]

I think the heart tag looks a bit young. I have and love the pave in medium/pave and love it and the smile line in general. It’s a happy collection. That gets my vote.