Help me decide between these two, please!

[Dolce]

They were both around the same price ($1200) and I have to return one. The picture is terrible because it's from my camera phone but I hope you could get an idea. The first one is 2 1/4 carats but they're small diamondsThe second one is the 1/2 carat one from Macy's http://www1.macys.com/catalog/product/index.ognc?ID=195883&CategoryID=21247 Help me out! Or if you have a better idea let me know! I love the simplicity and elegance of the pendant but I think it might just be too simple and small for me.

 

[Loganz]

I followed your link and I like the pendant. The first necklace kind of reminds me of a lariat - for that reason I am not a huge fan.

I can see why it is a hard decision - I know I would get more use out of the pendant necklace - what about you, what would you get more use out of?

 

[Dolce]

I'd probably get more use out of the pendant. And the quality of the stone is actually really nice. I just find that the necklace is more striking than the pendant. I bought the pendant first so I think I might just stick with my first choice. It's tough though!

 

[Lvbabydoll]

Definitely a hard decision...I like larger necklaces so I like the first one. But the second one is really pretty too.
I'd probably keep the pendant though, it's so nice!

 

[Lululovebags]

i would keep the pendant..

 

[killerstrawbery]

another pendant vote