I had one of each until recently. I took the Sophie back. I didn't like how it kind of crinkled, even while it was just in storage. I love slouchy bags, but not in the sophie. Now I swap out between my suttons and my selmas. I have the b&w colorblock sutton and was torn between the same two you have screenshots of. I just preferred the look of the sutton over the selma in colorblock. It sounds weird, but all the bags look different in certain colors. And, to give you an idea of the white stripe in the center, one day on my way into the office, I spilled coffee on my bag. Right on the white stripe. I about flipped in the elevator. But, a damp towel took it right off and no stains or remnants whatsoever. The saffiano leather is very durable and tolerant of an oops moment.