Help me choose!

[AutumnJade]

I know many of you are familiar with the concept of selling a bag before you buy one, but how do you choose which one to sell? I thought I would go through my collection and try to limit it to one bag per color but I need help with a few. Which bag would you keep or sell and why?

 

[AutumnJade]

Reds

 

[AutumnJade]

I included the red leather on this one just so you have a comparison to the other shades. I might pick two from these.

 

[AutumnJade]

Neither of these are coach but I'd like opinions on these as well.

 

[theheidis]

I know many of you are familiar with the concept of selling a bag before you buy one, but how do you choose which one to sell? I thought I would go through my collection and try to limit it to one bag per color but I need help with a few. Which bag would you keep or sell and why?

Does the one on the right have silver hardware?

 

[AutumnJade]

Yes

 

[whateve]

I love the red bucket bag. I would never part with that. I also love the purple ergo kisslock. I do think you could get a lot for that one if you sell it though. I like the brown Julianne better than the other brown (Soho?) I like all your pink and purple bags. I've never been a fan of the MK Hamilton, but I know there is a lot of love for that style.

If they were mine, I would sell the signature satchel, the brown Soho, and the two non-Coach. If I still needed to sell more, I would consider the glam. It is really cute, but personally, I don't need another bag this size.

 

[TooManyWantMore]

Pic#1 keep the one on the right
Pic#2 keep the one on the right
Pic #3 keep the one on the left
Pic #4 keep the one on the left
Pic#5 keep the one on the right

 

[INDRIDCOLD]

i would sell the saddle tan soho in pic one, the red leather hobo in 2,and the poppy in 3, i would also sell both the non coach bags.

 

[firstclasscoach]

I'd sell the black, the red siggy, the Poppy, the fuschia, and both non-Coach.

 

[Mom2jtv]

Pic 1 sell the one on the right

Pic 2 sell the one on the right

Pic 3 keep all but bottom right

Pic 4 sell both, I am partial to Coach

 

[mariak16]

1. keep right
2. keep left
3. keep top left and bottom right (but really I like them all!)
4. keep left (although I love Coach I also like MK and I really like that bag!)

 

[lurkernomore]

I love the Julianne, so I would not let either of those go. I also love the red bucket bag - the shape and the shade of red is perfect.
If you are not really in love with the Juliannes (although IMO that brown is the perfect shade of brown) then those would be good to sell because they still seem to sell at a strong pricepoint on ebay.
I have four Juliannes (brown siggy, your brown, your magenta, and teal). The longer I have them the more gorgeous they get - they really break in beautifully...

 

[AutumnJade]

I really love the Julianne's as well; such wonderful leather. I'm so torn, lol.

 

[whateve]

I really love the Julianne's as well; such wonderful leather. I'm so torn, lol.

The Juliannes and the ergo satchel are rare. If you sell them, it will be hard to find them again if you change your mind.