Kate Spade Help Me Choose Which Kate Spade!

[linhhhuynh]

Hey all. My friend's birthday is coming, and incidentally, I bought her something, but decided to keep it..... (don't judge me! ) so I need to find something else.

My friend is a HUGE makeup junkie, so my initial thought was this:


BUT this color is so cute, and um. The sale price is amazing, haha:

(if anyone has seen this color IRL let me know, some of the photos on Google look very green and neon, not as cute as the stock photo..)

Help me!

 

[alouette]

Lol. I can relate. No judging here!!

I prefer the second...fun and happy color for perhaps a fun and happy girl.

 

[tonij2000]

Yep, i've kept a thing or two originally purchased (by me) for someone else!

I like the second one as well.

 

[linhhhuynh]

Yay, so I'm not the only one!!! I did this for another friend's Christmas present... oops. I really like the 2nd, but am I getting more bang for the $ since the other one is bigger?

 

[BagaholicAnon]

I like the first one because it's bigger. The second is a cute color but it doesn't look like it'll hold much.

 

[curvednglam]

I love the color of the second one. Maybe the first one in a different color ?

 

[chanel*liz]

i love the color of the second but the size of the first.. does the first come in other colors? or does the second come in a larger size? it doesn't look like it would hold much makeup

 

[digby723]

I like the first one because it's bigger. The second is a cute color but it doesn't look like it'll hold much.

ITA, I think the first one is better for a makeup junkie. The 2nd one, although in a better, funkier print, won't hold much in comparison to the first choice (which is what I would go with if I were you).

 

[Loyal2Louis]

It depends on her personality. I'd think about what all of her other accessories tend to look like and try to go for that style. Both are wonderful choices though

 

[ilovekatespade]

second one is cuter!

 

[gidramom]

Seconds one says "Coin Purse" so maybe for some coins, credit cards and a lipstick? It's useful if your friend carries clutch. I have many of this size pouch (they are cute, aren't they?) but ended up not using at all....
First one is more like everyday use cosmetic case but the color is a bit ...boring?
How about this?
http://www.katespade.com/womens-wal...l?dwvar_PWRU1665_color=290&start=59&cgid=sale

 

[supersaucy]

First one for a makeup junkie to hold all her MAC.

 

[linhhhuynh]

i decided to get the 1st one since it's bigger and holds more makeup, even though the second one is soooo cute. we'll see when it comes. thanks for all the help!!