Help me choose please!

[Loco4Coco]

I’m trying to decide between these two bags. Help me choose please.

 

[AstridRhapsody]

I think both are gorgeous but I would use them completely differently. Do you need something to carry a lot like the dreamer 36 or just the basics for weekend shopping like the page?

 

[elvisfan4life]

The first one every time

 

[meepabeep]

The Oxblood Page.

 

[NOIRetMoi]

They are 2 completely different bags. What are you going to use this bag for? Does it matter or you’re just getting it because you like it? Do you have any other similar bags? Did you use them a lot? Yes? No? Why? Which one would you use the most?

If you flip a coin to decide which one to buy and it lands on bag 1 and you find yourself wishing it had landed on bag 2, it can be an indicator you have a preference for bag 2.

 

[gr8onteej]

I own the Page and I love it.

 

[Diamond Dazed]

The oxblood one.

 

[SEWDimples]

The Oxblood Page with Rivets is gorgeous.

 

[cielopark]

The oxblood page. its more versatile. Can you carry it as a clutch? Love the color

 

[gr8onteej]

The oxblood page. its more versatile. Can you carry it as a clutch? Love the color

I think it’s a little too big to carry as a clutch.
It actually holds a lot for a medium sized bag. I use it every day.

 

[barskin]

Okay. I love the Dreamer. I have one from last year. But, that version of the Dreamer is Hideous. Yecch. But, that is just my personal feeling.

 

[laurenrr]

i say the Dreamer. unique and looks super modern/cool

 

[Alexa5]

I agree. It depends on the size you need and what you are using it for.

 

[anthrosphere]

I held the Paige in the store before, the leather is so soft but structured, and the rivets adds such a cool edgy vibe to it. Plus I like how it closes, so you can be confident your stuff will be safe inside.

The Dreamer I like, but not that particular style. So I choose the Paige.

 

[barskin]

i say the Dreamer. unique and looks super modern/cool[

You see? You like that Dreamer, I hate it, and we are both correct - for ourselves. How you feel about a handbag is very personal, almost involuntary. It's like perfume; a scent that appeals to one person, might be unpleasant to another. It's not right or wrong. It is just how we individually experience it. That's why this thread baffles me. I can see asking questions about how bags hold up, does it keep it's shape, etc. But why should the OP care what bags we like? I love most of the Dreamers, but I hate the one pictured here - and why on earth should that matter to anyone else.