Help me choose my first Rolex!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

llalaill

O.G.
Mar 29, 2012
45
45
Hi everyone! I was hoping to get your opinions regarding a new Rolex watch. This will be my first high end watch and after looking at multiple different watches, I've narrowed it down to a Rolex datejust. Now I'm just trying to pick the details. I'm deciding between the 31mm and 36mm sizes and two tone with rose gold vs yellow gold. Deciding between diamond markers or roman numeral markers. I definitely want a MOP dial, domed bezel, and jubilee bracelet.

For a little background on myself, I just turned 30. I don't wear a lot of jewelry but always wear my VCA alhambra bracelet (in the pictures) and sometimes my Cartier love bangle (was on my left wrist when I tried on the watches), occasionally some diamond studs or simple earrings. I'm ok with switching my VCA bracelet to the other wrist if it clashes with the watch. I usually dress pretty casually except for work, which is business casual. I work in a pretty conservative environment so don't want to be too flashy. I definitely want this to be my everyday watch and am planning on getting another watch as a dressy watch in the future.

I've included some pictures of the watches I tried on in store. They didn't have the exact combination I wanted but at least got some idea. I'm sorry for the huge picture sizes! Don't know how to size them down. Please let me know your opinions about which size is better (31mm vs 36mm), which color choice (rose vs yellow gold), and what markers (diamond vs roman numerals). Any other opinions/suggestions/advice recommended as well. Thanks so much! And sorry for the long post!

1. Datejust - 36mm, stainless steel with yellow gold, MOP dial with diamond markers

IMG_7348.JPG
IMG_7349.JPG


2. Datejust - 31mm, stainless steel with rose gold, MOP dial with roman numeral markers (this one has the diamond VI but I don't love it, would do diamond or roman numeral only markers)

IMG_7387.JPG
IMG_7388.JPG
 
Hi everyone! I was hoping to get your opinions regarding a new Rolex watch. This will be my first high end watch and after looking at multiple different watches, I've narrowed it down to a Rolex datejust. Now I'm just trying to pick the details. I'm deciding between the 31mm and 36mm sizes and two tone with rose gold vs yellow gold. Deciding between diamond markers or roman numeral markers. I definitely want a MOP dial, domed bezel, and jubilee bracelet.

For a little background on myself, I just turned 30. I don't wear a lot of jewelry but always wear my VCA alhambra bracelet (in the pictures) and sometimes my Cartier love bangle (was on my left wrist when I tried on the watches), occasionally some diamond studs or simple earrings. I'm ok with switching my VCA bracelet to the other wrist if it clashes with the watch. I usually dress pretty casually except for work, which is business casual. I work in a pretty conservative environment so don't want to be too flashy. I definitely want this to be my everyday watch and am planning on getting another watch as a dressy watch in the future.

I've included some pictures of the watches I tried on in store. They didn't have the exact combination I wanted but at least got some idea. I'm sorry for the huge picture sizes! Don't know how to size them down. Please let me know your opinions about which size is better (31mm vs 36mm), which color choice (rose vs yellow gold), and what markers (diamond vs roman numerals). Any other opinions/suggestions/advice recommended as well. Thanks so much! And sorry for the long post!

1. Datejust - 36mm, stainless steel with yellow gold, MOP dial with diamond markers

View attachment 3460369
View attachment 3460370


2. Datejust - 31mm, stainless steel with rose gold, MOP dial with roman numeral markers (this one has the diamond VI but I don't love it, would do diamond or roman numeral only markers)

View attachment 3460371
View attachment 3460372
This is my watch. Got it 4 years ago and still love it. I love the 31, love the rose gold and love the MOP dial with RN and diamond VI. Would buy the same one again.
 
The first one looks gorgeous on you.. I love its big size on your hand.. And the stainless gold in my opinion looks more beautiful on your tone.. I am all the way a voter for diamond markers (i called them in another thread confetti! They just look gorgeous and so young yet classy)
Good luck with your purchase :flowers:
 
  • Like
Reactions: uhpharm01
Hi everyone! I was hoping to get your opinions regarding a new Rolex watch. This will be my first high end watch and after looking at multiple different watches, I've narrowed it down to a Rolex datejust. Now I'm just trying to pick the details. I'm deciding between the 31mm and 36mm sizes and two tone with rose gold vs yellow gold. Deciding between diamond markers or roman numeral markers. I definitely want a MOP dial, domed bezel, and jubilee bracelet.

For a little background on myself, I just turned 30. I don't wear a lot of jewelry but always wear my VCA alhambra bracelet (in the pictures) and sometimes my Cartier love bangle (was on my left wrist when I tried on the watches), occasionally some diamond studs or simple earrings. I'm ok with switching my VCA bracelet to the other wrist if it clashes with the watch. I usually dress pretty casually except for work, which is business casual. I work in a pretty conservative environment so don't want to be too flashy. I definitely want this to be my everyday watch and am planning on getting another watch as a dressy watch in the future.

I've included some pictures of the watches I tried on in store. They didn't have the exact combination I wanted but at least got some idea. I'm sorry for the huge picture sizes! Don't know how to size them down. Please let me know your opinions about which size is better (31mm vs 36mm), which color choice (rose vs yellow gold), and what markers (diamond vs roman numerals). Any other opinions/suggestions/advice recommended as well. Thanks so much! And sorry for the long post!

1. Datejust - 36mm, stainless steel with yellow gold, MOP dial with diamond markers

View attachment 3460369
View attachment 3460370


2. Datejust - 31mm, stainless steel with rose gold, MOP dial with roman numeral markers (this one has the diamond VI but I don't love it, would do diamond or roman numeral only markers)

View attachment 3460371
View attachment 3460372
I like the second in the 31mm size but in steel and yellow gold instead of the Rose gold
 
I like the 31 mm, stainless with yellow gold and Roman numerals. Save the diamonds for when you get the dressy watch!

This is my watch. Got it 4 years ago and still love it. I love the 31, love the rose gold and love the MOP dial with RN and diamond VI. Would buy the same one again.

The first one looks gorgeous on you.. I love its big size on your hand.. And the stainless gold in my opinion looks more beautiful on your tone.. I am all the way a voter for diamond markers (i called them in another thread confetti! They just look gorgeous and so young yet classy)
Good luck with your purchase :flowers:

I like the second in the 31mm size but in steel and yellow gold instead of the Rose gold

I like the 31. I think the 36 is a bit too large on you.

I loooooovw the second one the way that it is!!



Thanks so much for responding and your advice! I'm going to go back to my local Rolex store again to try on the watches. The SA in store definitely felt the 36mm was better on me, but now I can't tell based on the pictures! I'm a little worried that the two tone Rolex may be too flashy for every day wear but will look again!
 
  • Like
Reactions: uhpharm01
I vote smaller too. I also wouldn't hesitate to wait and find the one that makes your heart sing, if these don't do it. Prices (discounts?) could also come down as year-end approaches and retailers get more desperate.
 
Well, let me just say I LOVE rolex 36mm- I have it and love it (see my avatar) That being said, I REALLY love the 31 on you in the stainless and rose gold combo (second one). I think it's absolutely stunning on you and totally goes with your skin tone!!! No doubt- it's fabulous on you!
 
Top