Help me choose a tote - Tod's vs Serapian

[ClaphamTulip]

Hi! I'm looking for a convenient underarm tote for all seasons. I'm hesisating between:

https://www.tods.com/gb-en/p/XBWAPAF9300QRI9P13/?ds_rl=1292021&ds_rl=1292021&gclid=CjwKCAjwiOCgBhAgEiwAjv5whAPaxNyJfbA561knW4PoU4w5sOLOOW0bs5I_0n0_InvBEFboKFxMiRoClhcQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

or

SMALL SECRET TOTE BAG IN RUGIADA LEATHER

The soft and supple Small Secret Tote Bag in Cuoio Rugiada leather is a lightweight, roomy everyday tote for women seeking practical elegance. It is an all-rounder with plenty of inner pockets and compartments. Each creation is meticulously handcrafted by expert craftsmen to create a true emblem...

www.serapian.com

Both are very similar but would love your input!

 

[indiaink]

Tod's looks a bit more organized... and it is a gorgeous time-tested bag.

But then the clasp on the Serapian Small Secret tote might be easier to handle.

Beauty and organization vs ease of access. Hmmm...

 

[Mariapia]

The Tod’s is fabulous .

 

[Mirus’ Dream]

Tod’s

 

[muchstuff]

They’re both good-looking bags but the Tod’s is more interesting. Love the way the handles join the bag.

 

[serenityneow]

For what it's worth, I decided I liked the Serapian better after thinking about the size of bag I really want and need. The Tod's is significantly larger and considerably more than I need based on my laptop's dimensions. Particularly since I have a small frame, I'm worried about the appearance of a larger-than-necessary bag. And FYI, the small Serapian is now on sale! I pulled the trigger -- will post again once I receive it! https://www.net-a-porter.com/en-us/...small-textured-leather-tote/42247633208332715

 

[Joeli7]

For what it's worth, I decided I liked the Serapian better after thinking about the size of bag I really want and need. The Tod's is significantly larger and considerably more than I need based on my laptop's dimensions. Particularly since I have a small frame, I'm worried about the appearance of a larger-than-necessary bag. And FYI, the small Serapian is now on sale! I pulled the trigger -- will post again once I receive it! https://www.net-a-porter.com/en-us/...small-textured-leather-tote/42247633208332715

This is such a pretty bag, are you happy with it?

 

[serenityneow]

I ended up returning the camel one I got from Net-a-Porter, but couldn't get the bag out of my mind. So, I now own black and Sahara ones and adore them - https://forum.purseblog.com/threads...a-photo-with-us.924408/page-538#post-35715987. I seriously think they're perfect--leather, style, organization, handle drop, compartments etc.