Help ,in deciding DBTY

[umamanikam]

I am unsure whether to get the platinum .12 from tiffany or white gold .24 ideal cut ,D color ,vvs from Blue nile .
The tifanny is £695 and the Blue nile is £557 .
I did not wnt a large one .
which one is better in relation to shine and workmanship of thbezel and chain .
Going through the threads have made me more confused.
TIA

 

[Candice0985]

I voted for tiffany, you want quality in the bezel work and super sparkly diamond. then definitley tiffany. I know i have talked about my platinum dbty bracelet millions of times but even though the diamonds are small they throw major fire and the bezels are very fine and immaculately made.

 

[Kitsunegrl]

I also choose Tiffany for the delicacy of the workmanship.

I think Blue Nile offers a decent product, but it is definitely chunkier.

 

[skyqueen]

^^I think there are photos somewhere showing the difference in the chain/bezel. Tiffanys was more delicate.

 

[skphotoimages]

I have the Bluenile one and I had the Brian Gavin one which is identical to the Tiffany's one. The chain is definitly nicer and daintier on the Tiffany's one. I kept the Blue Nile because I didn't like the poking of the Tiffany's style. The Blue nile one is in a bit more of a basket. I also personally like the thicker chain on the Bluenile one.
But if you are going for just a bit of sparkle at the neckline, I'd go for Tiffany's.

 

[AntiqueShopper]

I voted for the Tiffany one. I have owned and worn mine for years (I have the .14).

 

[luvmy3girls]

Tiffany for sure! I have one and love it

 

[Bagaday]

I have the Tiffany's 5 station DBTY and I adore it. It's very well made and they definitely have a 'leg up' regarding the workmanship/less-metal-is-better bezel.

PS I work in a jewelry store (10 yrs now) and am almost embarrassed to admit that I bought one from Tiffany's but have absolutely no regret - except for the $$ spent of course.

 

[shells]

i voted tiffany...but i also recently discovered that roberto coin has a similar style to tiffany's, HOWEVER, there are two different chains available on their dbty, a thicker one and a thinner one. i prefer the thinner chain, which is why i voted tiffanys. i have a thread i recently posted showing the differences between their chains

 

[daluu]

tiffany's for sure. the chain is thinner but it is just as sturdy. it truly looks like it's floating.

 

[darkangel07760]

I voted on the Tiffany one, because I think that it is better quality.
Good luck with your decision!