Help, I Can't Decide on a Color!

[HollsMM]

I'm looking to purchase a YSL Cassandra in the medium size with a top handle. Since it is rather pricey I'd like it to be a year round bag, so which color would best work for that? I don't want black because I already have one and really wanted a fun, bright color that could be worn during all seasons. YSL tends to use such a dark palette, though. There's an ivory but would that be winter appropriate? Then there's a warm beige but the hardware is silver and I just think gold would've looked so much better. Finally, the red one is quite dark. I've attached pictures of all 3 for reference. Thanks for helping a girl in need out!

 

[IntheOcean]

I think all of those would be perfectly appropriate for all seasons, winter included. The third one maybe less so because it has quite a warm undertone, but you have to take into account your winter wardrobe as well.

I'd pick the oxblood/purple one.

 

[HollsMM]

I think all of those would be perfectly appropriate for all seasons, winter included. The third one maybe less so because it has quite a warm undertone, but you have to take into account your winter wardrobe as well.

I'd pick the oxblood/purple one.

That's the one I'm leaning towards actually. It'd be a heck of a lot easier to keep clean also. Thanks for your input!

 

[muchstuff]

I think all of those would be perfectly appropriate for all seasons, winter included. The third one maybe less so because it has quite a warm undertone, but you have to take into account your winter wardrobe as well.

I'd pick the oxblood/purple one.

+1.

 

[IntheOcean]

That's the one I'm leaning towards actually. It'd be a heck of a lot easier to keep clean also. Thanks for your input!

Oh yes, it'll definitely be more carefree than the other two!

 

[vesna]

+1.

+1

 

[EveyB]

I would choose the burgundy. It appears to be a beautiful shade of burgundy and it goes with almost everything.

 

[tblusmama]

I would go with oxblood, it's a beautiful color and will be great for all seasons. That's just my humble opinion

 

[Katinahat]

I’m with everyone else in picking the darkest colour from the three. Just my thoughts but I feel it would be easier to use year round which is what you say you want. All lovely though!

 

[Yasmarea]

Oxblood for sure! It’s such a classy year round color. I would go for the white as a second choice only if you can keep it clean and pristine.

 

[SpicyTuna13]

Burgundy

 

[yellowbernie]

Burgundy

 

[girliegirl]

Burgundy

 

[HollsMM]

Sadly I bought the burgundy bag but am returning it. The logo clasp is way too flimsy and can be opened by pulling on it. Also, the shoulder strap falls at a weird, too-short length on me when worn crossbody. My hunt for the perfect structured top handle bag continues (until I can afford a Kelly ). I have my sights set on the Chloe Aby in the same color next...

 

[Sterntalerli]

I would take the last one if I were you