I am not sure that reeking of cigarette smoke woul be deemed as not as described by paypal , it is horrible but you might lose , its normally only if something is broken or fake that they side with the buyer . It is so hard to get rid of that smell i feel for you .
Thanks for your response. Actually, I was going based on the fact that she already told me she was going to give me a partial refund. I have email proof and everything. She never followed through with her word which is the only reason why I filed a dispute. If she would have said a flat out no I would have negged her on ebay, but now she's no longer registered.