Help deciding on color!

  1. What would you guys do?
    I have a pair of caged patent poudre rockstuds. I wear a Sz 8 US, but the 38.5 in patent were still too small, so I went up a size and bought the 39. Now, after wearing a bit, they've stretched and are a tad too big. I'm selling them and have bought another pair in leather Sz 38.5. Now the leather ones fit great, but my problem is this:
    I bought them from Saks and their pic showed a taupe color that looked like poudre and the color listed said "taupe". I received them and they are definitely tan (I'm wondering if they are alpaca? The color code is P30). I'm trying to decide if I should keep or return and wait to find the leather poudre somewhere. I LOVE the poudre color. I'm a sucker for pinky or grey neutrals. However, I keep hearing the leather version is more susceptible to scuffing. If that's the case, is it wiser to keep the darker neutral? What would you do? Help! ImageUploadedByPurseForum1461524580.179209.jpg
  2. I love this color on you!! It is a really pretty neutral.
  3. Thank you so much! I feel like I just need a nudge.