Help deciding between 2 Tiffany mini heart lock necklace with slight flaws

[AnnaBananna]

There are only 2 left of this necklace at my local tiffany stores and the sales person told me it's being discontinued. After inspecting both of the same necklace for about 5mins..

1. has a very tiny dent (more like an imprint) on the bottom near the point of the heart. The size is about 50% of the copyright symbol.

2. for the tiffany logo imprint, the circle around the copyright symbol isnt complete about 25% is missing.

Which one would you choose?

Thank you in advance for your input!

The stock photo for reference.

 

[Nymf]

Choose another necklace you love or have one shipped from another country/state?

 

[alliemia]

No. 2

 

[rengb6]

Tiffany's shouldn't be trying to sell damaged goods IMO. Are you able to order it online?

 

[katierose]

Choose another necklace you love or have one shipped from another country/state?

Tiffany's shouldn't be trying to sell damaged goods IMO. Are you able to order it online?

Agree!
I'd have them find me another perfect one.

 

[Perfect in Pink]

Neither. Have them call another store, find one in perfect shape, and have that shipped to you. The shipping should be free. I just did this today for a planner I forgot to order until it went out of stock online, and they got one from another store and are having it shipped to my house.

No reason to settle, someone has to have a good one somewhere.

 

[amateurjeweler]

No. 2 if you're okay with it, neither if you just know it would bother you.

Honestly these necklaces weren't more than $300 initially and have ballooned to $550. They were severely marked up to begin with, and factoring in an approximate 100% price increase since their debut, I don't get why Tiffany can't execute them perfectly and pull damaged items out of circulation.

 

[AnnaBananna]

Thanks everyone for the input! I'm going tomrrow to see if they would be willing to order one in for me

 

[dkgirl503]

#2