Ankorchick -
I have the Ana in chocolate and love the bag for these reasons:
#1) the leather is so soft and yummy without a "distressed" look that other HH bags have. It has a rich look to it - not a matte finish.
#2) it isn't a huge bag, which is what I need. The depth is only a couple of inches at most, so if you need to stuff a lot of things in the bag, suggest you get the Beatrice.
#3) the shoulder straps stay on my shoulders. They are not wide and thus are very comfortable ANd the bag hangs nicely from the shoulder
#4) pockets and organization. I read from other treads that HH bags were designed with function in mind and yup, they do a great job. There's a pocket on the outside where I hold my keys and then there's the hidden flap that is magnetized and I can slip pieces of paper in here.
#5) the "look"....it is different looking....I don't want a bag that looks like so many others.
The only "fault" I find w/the bag is that the opening is not so big, which of course is attributed to the design. IMO, well worth it since I don't carry bulky things.
Hope this helps and love the suggestion that you get both......and then decide.
Good luck, let us know what you've picked.
Once you get an HH bag, you know that they are a great value, well construced, nicely designed and worth it!