Harry Winston Sunflower vs Tiffany Flower??

claudia09

Member
Dec 28, 2009
210
1
Went shopping with the BF and have been looking at jewelry for our 3 yrs - we are considering the Harry Winston Sunflower ring as an option, waiting on them to ship the ring in in my size, but I do have a few uncertainties.

http://www.harrywinston.com/store/jewels/rings-jewels/products/006asunflowerdiamondring

I saw that Tiffany's has a similar design that is cute, smaller diamonds but also much cheaper. It's like 1.65 vs .6 CTW.

http://www.tiffany.com/Shopping/Ite...-c+-r+-x+-n+6-ri+-ni+0-t+flower+ring&search=1

I think the center stone in the HW that I'm considering is .74 F VS2 and GIA certified. Tiffany diamonds in the ring are much smaller in the ring and I believe they don't certify most of their diamonds thru a 3rd party.

Do you guys think the HW is worth it? Anyone have modeling pics of either one?
 

karo

O.G.
Sep 5, 2006
18,872
33
Both are gorgeous, but personally I would go for the Tiffany one. I think the flower stands out more with the plain band than with the diamond one.
 
I think the HW is stunning! IMO, the Tiffany one looks more like a snowflake to me.. But is still beautiful. But that's just me. Tacori also makes a floral halo setting but its a totally different look with the way the halo is set (mine is Tacori floral 'inspired' made by my jeweler)
 

AndieAbroad

UK via AUS and USA
Dec 1, 2012
398
2
The HW looks more like it could be an engagement ring to me. I also prefer the Tiffany one, which is a bit more delicate. I agree it looks more like a snowflake, though! heh
 

ehy210

Member
Apr 21, 2011
818
6
both are beautiful. I would pick the Tiffany's one. I like how the petals are more pointed- it would look very nice on the finger. I don't like how the HW one has petals that are circular. But both are beautiful.
 

claudia09

Member
Dec 28, 2009
210
1
Thanks girls!

The HW is $19.6k and Tiffanys is $4.5k.

The price difference is pretty big.

Alternatively, we were considering the Cariter Juste Un Clou / WG Love Bracelet or the VCA socrates... :hrmm:

IDK! They're all so beautiful, but just so different, so hard to decide. What do you guys think?
 
Last edited:
Aug 31, 2009
4,160
15
Well I think the price should probably dictate. Are you looking for a 4.5 type present or a 20k type present? Then I would browse around in that price range. As you really can't compare Harry Winston to Tiffany's, they are in different leagues. I would choose HW as nothing compares :hbeat:
 
Jun 8, 2007
353
3
Cartier WG Love Bracelet or the VCA socrates sound better to me. :smile:
I own the tiffany flower ring, I really love it. it is pretty and not overwhelming. all the options are very different. really depending on what you are looking for. a casual ring or everyday, engagement or cocktail? I love the three socrates ring from VCA. that's more of a cocktail ring. the single flower one is a little too delicate.
 

jssl1688

Member
Jul 12, 2012
830
1,353
Heaven on Earth
Harry winston > Tiffany I don't think there's a comparison. However if we're talking about having a jeweler design it and sourcing your own stone that may be a choice if cost is a concern. Harry does have a hefty premium.